Disclaimer Note: I have not been in U.S.A, I know about the U.S
only from movies, news and some of my friends there. Hence, there is a good
chance that whatever I am writing is based on ignorance, so continue reading
with that in mind.
Last weekend, just like the news shocked anyone else, I too
was in a state of horror learning the mass massacre/shooting of the kids (aged
5-10) by Lanza (a 20 year old guy). For those who are not aware, Lanza, armed
with a couple of guns, walked into a school, and shot dead 20 kids and 6
adults.
When I had a chat with one of my friend in the U.S, he said
people there were very insecure. It was possible for anyone to come over and
knock your door at night, threaten/kill you and walk away with your possessions.
He was almost mugged by a guy at 6:30 pm in the town. It could be that
insecurity that drives them to possess guns, for self-defense, for protecting themselves, and their family. And according to him, these are not some individual incidents, and they are common in many parts of the U.S.
Now, there are two probable solutions possible here. One,
make guns legal, and let the citizens use it. Two, enact tougher and stricter
laws to prevent mugging/theft/small crimes/drug abuse/alcohol abuse etc. U.S.A
went with the first one. Possession of guns is legal, and people can use guns
for self-defense according to the second amendment (even if the intention was
not self defense when the amendment was made). The flip side is what you see
nowadays, a new shooting incident every 2 months or so.
Why not the second choice? Why not enact tough laws to
prevent small mishaps? For that, one might need to look into the reason causing
mugging and thefts. Or may be ask ourselves the question, “What would make me
steal?”. Nothing, but economic problem. We do not have money, our family is dependent on us, we do
not have a job, we cannot earn, and we have to provide bread for our family.
Yes, that can make us steal. And
probably, that is what that makes them steal too. Now, why is it hard to find a job and earn in the U.S?
Simply put, America is a country ruled by the
corporate. The big industries of oil, weapon, banks and retail decides “what
next” (more or less true). And in retail, who is bigger than the “Wal-Mart”?
They have driven out every possible small scale and medium scale businesses. A
good majority of these small businessmen and their employees turn jobless, and
according to my friend, there are quite a lot Americans who find it difficult
to get a job.
My friend told me about a ridiculous practice that exists in
U.S - price-matching. He receives a number of ad-posters via mail, and he can
check that and find out the lowest price for every item. He can go to Wal-Mart
with that, and they will give you the item for that lowest price. Now, do you
think, any small-scale or medium-scale business can survive there, when you have
a “Wal-Mart” which provides all the goods at the least possible price? I
remember reading an article in "The Hindu" by Sainath, which stated that the size of
onions in U.S is controlled by Wal-Mart. They make the onion size bigger so
that people throw away after using the first half, and they come sooner for the
next purchase. The article was mainly about the decline of the small family owned
farms in U.S.
Now, if you think the lawmakers are going to do anything
against the corporate, you can refer the source of the biggest fund for
election campaign for both the parties. That will answer your question beyond
doubt. If you ask me, I do not know a solution here, either that a strong leader should emerge, else undoubtedly, America is heading towards a revolution, sooner or later.
Coming back to the mass killings, people who tend to do these
mass killings may be driven by mental issues. Either that they are born with
mental issues, or society turns them insane. It might be that they do not get
enough attention from family or friends because their character/personality/looks is different.
The social stigma associated could probably cause depression, and drive them
towards mental illness. As important as it is for the state to provide better
mental health care institutes, it is important for the rest of the society to
accept them as one amongst us, and act in a non-prejudiced way. Along with
that, the media and the entertainment industry also need to evolve. Glorifying wars,
killings, villains and violence plays an important role in shaping the young
minds. When the state via media provides a “reason” for war which kills
millions, the young can easily imbibe on it, and find a reason for killing a
few.
Now, coming back to guns, I am completely against making
guns legal. Even if a person encounters economic/social/mental problems, he can
shoot and kill people only if he carries a gun. Making guns legal facilitates
that. Of course, one can obtain guns
illegally and use them, but that is another story, which can again be prevented
with tougher laws. Just the day before the Newtown incident, a guy in China
stabbed a few school children. A horrendous incident, but still in light of the
Newtown incident, does not the “stabbing” sound better? Of course, a root cause
analysis of the problem is important, improvement of economic and social
conditions, improvement of mental healthcare facilities, all are good, and will
do well in the long run. But, what can be done to prevent occurrence of such incidents
in the near future? Well, the answer is simple, ban guns, why do ordinary citizens need guns? Don't the guns cause more harm than help? Do the guns really help you when you are in a dangerous situation? Or are the guns just an illusion of safety?
People abroad say it is very dangerous to travel to India. India
is insecure, you may be robbed, you will encounter eve-teasing etc etc. True, I
am not denying the existence of robbery or eve-teasing in India. But, even with
all this, we learn to live without guns. Till date, parents in India can send
kids to school without the tension of them getting shot. Yes, there is a lot of
difference between 4000 year old India and 250 year old “evolving” America. But
still, some facts are facts.
May be the Newtown shooting and the tiny smiling faces will remain etched in our
memories forever. Or, will it? Just like Newtown made Oregon or Colorado
“easily forgotten", it might be only a matter of time till another mass
massacre makes this one look small.